Quality journalism, one article at a time
There is a stretch of road in the continental United States unlike any other. U.S. Highway 1 south of Homestead, Florida, becomes something transcendent — a 113-mile ribbon of asphalt that hops across 42 bridges, threading together a chain of coral-and-mangrove islands where the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico lie so close you can see both from the same spot. This is the Florida Keys, and it remains one of America's most singular travel destinations.
Whether you're chasing the legendary tarpon and bonefish of Islamorada, sipping a frozen rum drink at sunset in Key West's Mallory Square, or doing absolutely nothing in a hammock strung between two palms on Bahia Honda, the Keys deliver a specific, irreplaceable kind of freedom. The trick, as any veteran visitor will tell you, is knowing how to do it right.
Most visitors fly into Miami International or Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International and rent a car, and this is the right call. The Overseas Highway — the colloquial name for U.S. 1 through the Keys — is a driving experience in its own right. Give yourself a full day for the journey if you can afford it. Stop at the Alabama Jack's roadhouse at Card Sound Road for a cold beer and a crab cake before you even cross the first bridge. Pull over at the Long Key State Park lookout. Do not, under any circumstances, try to drive straight through to Key West in one shot without stopping — you will regret it for the rest of your life.
The Keys are divided informally into the Upper Keys (Key Largo down to Islamorada), the Middle Keys (Marathon and the Seven Mile Bridge), and the Lower Keys (Big Pine Key down through Stock Island), with Key West standing somewhat apart as its own eccentric republic. Each zone has a distinct personality, and serious visitors often plant themselves in one area rather than trying to cover all 125 miles in a long weekend.
Key Largo bills itself as the Diving Capital of the World, and it has a reasonable claim. John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park, the first undersea park in the United States, protects 70 nautical square miles of coral reef just offshore. The park's dive operators run multiple trips daily to sites like Molasses Reef and the famous Christ of the Abyss statue — a nine-foot bronze figure submerged in 25 feet of crystal water whose outstretched arms have become one of the most photographed underwater images in the world.
Non-divers aren't left out. The park rents glass-bottom boats that give a dazzling view of the reef system, and the snorkeling is accessible enough for competent swimmers of any age. The Dolphin Research Center on Grassy Key — technically in the Middle Keys but worth the mention — offers supervised swim programs with Atlantic bottlenose dolphins that book up months in advance.
Islamorada is where serious anglers make their pilgrimages. The "Village of Islands" (Islamorada is actually a collection of several small keys) sits atop what fishing guides call "the flats" — vast shallow-water expanses where bonefish, permit, and tarpon cruise in water so clear you can see them from fifty feet away. Fly fishing the flats for tarpon, which can exceed 100 pounds, is considered one of the supreme technical challenges in all of recreational fishing.
The Cheeca Lodge & Spa remains the grande dame of Keys resorts — a sprawling Old Florida property with its own fishing pier, saltwater lagoon, and enough history to fill a magazine feature. The Thai Breeze restaurant at the Green Turtle Inn, open since 1947, is the kind of place that makes you understand why people retire to the Keys and never leave. Order the yellowtail snapper if it's on the menu. It will have been caught that morning.
Marathon is the working heart of the Middle Keys — more blue-collar and lived-in than the resort zones to the north and south, and better for it. The Florida Keys Marathon Airport offers direct flights from a handful of cities if you want to skip Miami entirely. The Turtle Hospital, a working rehabilitation facility for sea turtles, offers tours that are genuinely moving — you will leave with strong feelings about monofilament fishing line and plastic bags.
The Seven Mile Bridge, which connects Marathon to the Lower Keys, deserves its own paragraph. The current bridge, completed in 1982, replaced Henry Flagler's original 1912 railroad bridge — portions of which still stand alongside it, now converted to a walking and fishing pier. Driving across at sunrise, with the light turning the water from pewter to turquoise to deep blue, is one of those experiences that gets filed permanently under "why I travel."
Key West is 90 miles from Cuba and a world apart from the mainland. The southernmost city in the continental United States has been reinventing itself for two centuries — from wreckers and sponge fishermen to Ernest Hemingway and Tennessee Williams to the gay rights movement to the cruise ship day-tripper economy it navigates today. The bones of something genuinely strange and wonderful are still visible if you get off Duval Street.
Stay in the historic district if your budget allows. The guesthouses on the quieter side streets — Angela, Olivia, William — are a different experience than the Duval corridor hotels. Rent a bicycle. Eat at Blue Heaven in Bahama Village for breakfast on weekends, where roosters wander between the tables and the French toast has been making people emotional since 1992. Visit the Key West Cemetery, where the tombstones include "I told you I was sick" and an entire section of sailors from the USS Maine.
Mallory Square at sunset is genuinely worth experiencing once, crowds and all. The nightly Sunset Celebration has been happening every evening since the 1960s, and there is something quietly remarkable about a city that has institutionalized stopping everything to watch the sun go down.
Book accommodations early — the Keys have limited inventory and high demand year-round, with peak season running roughly November through April. Hurricane season (June through November) brings lower prices and real weather risk; September and October are the most active months. The Keys were significantly impacted by Hurricane Irma in 2017 and have largely rebuilt, but infrastructure can still feel stretched in spots.
Bring reef-safe sunscreen — Florida law now prohibits the sale of sunscreens containing oxybenzone and octinoxate, chemicals that damage coral reefs. This is not performative environmentalism; the reef system these islands depend on economically and ecologically is genuinely fragile. The water here is worth protecting.
Finally: slow down. The Keys operate on their own schedule. Traffic on U.S. 1 moves at 45 mph and there are no passing lanes. Locals have a name for this enforced deceleration — they call it "getting on Keys time" — and the ones who've been here longest will tell you it's not a bug, it's the whole point.